Way back in 2021, I sent my publishers at Hardie Grant an email titled “Pitchin’ Pictures.” Attached to the email was my very first draft of A Recipe for Magic Potion, and if I can give myself a compliment, it was a very good first draft. The book’s title was already locked in, and only a few stray “ands” and a line about old waxy honeycomb got cut during the editorial process. All it needed was some beautiful art from Natasja Horne and Magic Potion was ready to launch as my picture book debut.
But I also attached another manuscript to that email, titled The Little Bobby. The book was based around a simple idea that had amused me greatly: what if I wrote a piece of crime fiction for the youngest possible audience? And so I had crafted a series of five very silly criminal escapades, with the child reader invited to help the titular Little Bobby crack each case.
Between each case the book also took some time to follow the Little Bobby as he wandered through town, which I pictured as a quaint and whimsical English village. The rhythm of this interstitial text very clearly apes the style of one of my all-time literary heroes, the great Allan Ahlberg, and specifically his wonderful work on the Jolly Postman series. Here is how the book began:

I also thought it might be nice for the book to feature courtroom trials and criminal rehabilitation, to add a few shades of grey that are otherwise lacking in the standard childhood conception of cops and robbers. Writing that out now sounds absolutely bonkers, but in that very first draft I think it actually worked out to be kind of sweet:

Anyway, to cut a piece of kidlit crime fiction short: The Little Bobby was not picked up by my publisher. This was an incredibly reasonable reaction, as the available spots on a publisher’s list are finite, and splitting the difference between “fun and unique concept” and “commercial viability” is a very delicate balance. But rejection is always still a bummer, and The Little Bobby slunk sadly to the bottom of my writing folder, never to be seen again.
Well… kind of.
In early 2023, Scholastic Australia reached out to me to see if I had any fun ideas that might be a good fit for their list. I think they were looking for something in the vein of Cross Bones, but I (riskily) pitched them The Little Bobby instead. And, to my enormous delight, they dug it!
They did request some changes, though. The most exciting part of the book is obviously the burglaries, where the reader gets to join in and solve the mystery. Could the book spend less time following the Little Bobby on his wanderings, and instead squeeze in a couple more of those captivating crimes?
“Yeah,” I said. “I definitely think it could.”
And so this, at long last, is GOTCHA! — my brand new picture book. Of the original prose, only one (recurring) couplet remains; the rest is all brand new, born from the ashes of The Little Bobby into this sleek collection of five ELEVEN mini-mysteries for young readers. I’m so proud of this concept for finally reaching fruition, and for arriving with double the cases I originally imagined. I think it’s an absolute blast.
I also can’t go any further without mentioning the amazing artwork from James Hart, who went above and beyond in bringing these kleptomanic creatures to life. James is one of the crown jewel creators in Scholastic’s crown, so having him assigned to this project (amid all his other prolific output) was a tremendous vote of confidence. You can read a little bit about GOTCHA!‘s evolving cover art on James’s blog over here.
So that is the long and winding story of my latest story. GOTCHA! is my twelfth published book, and it landed in bookshops at the start of April. You can go and solve these mysteries, right now! Buy it for the child in your life who likes a good puzzle, or for anyone who might appreciate a cast of crazy animals dressed as characters from an Agatha Christie novel.
GOTCHA! isn’t really the same book as The Little Bobby, but it was interesting for me to write this post to try and track how one morphed into the other — and also nice to share a little bit of the original Bobby, now that it’s been completely overwritten. This is by far the biggest change any of my books have undergone from first draft to finished product, so hopefully it was interesting for you to follow along too.
And that’s the post. Go and buy GOTCHA! — out now!












